Cover artwork for Beyond the Transaction, Issue #03: The Courage to Disappoint

I've spent more than 30 years in business.

I've negotiated complex deals, built companies, advised executives, challenged conventional thinking, and navigated some pretty difficult professional situations.

I've never been particularly afraid of a tough business conversation.

But there's something I've struggled with for most of my life.

Disappointing people.

More specifically, the fear that if I disappointed someone, they wouldn't like me.

And that fear has cost me far more than I care to admit.

It's cost me money. Significant amounts of money.

It's cost me time, energy, relationships, and opportunities.

It's created stress, resentment, overcommitment, and more than a few situations where I found myself asking:

How the hell did I get myself into this mess?

The uncomfortable answer?

More often than not, I put myself there.

Not because I lacked intelligence, experience, or good intentions.

But because somewhere along the way, I'd developed a powerful need to be liked, appreciated, and accepted.

And for much of my life, I confused making other people happy with being a good person.

I'm beginning to understand just how expensive that confusion has been.

The Professional People-Pleaser

If there were a professional certification for people-pleasing, I'd probably have earned it decades ago.

I've said yes when I wanted to say no.

I've committed to things I didn't have the time, energy, or desire to do.

I've taken on responsibilities that weren't mine to carry.

I've compromised my priorities to accommodate someone else's.

And I've convinced myself that I was simply being helpful, generous, supportive, or a good partner.

Sometimes I was.

But sometimes, if I'm willing to be completely honest with myself, I was doing those things because I wanted something in return.

Not necessarily money.

Not necessarily recognition.

I wanted to be liked.

I wanted people to appreciate me.

I wanted them to see me as someone they could count on.

And perhaps most importantly, I didn't want them to be disappointed in me.

There's nothing wrong with wanting to help people.

There's nothing wrong with being generous, dependable, or compassionate.

But I've learned that there's an enormous difference between helping someone because you genuinely want to and helping someone because you're afraid of what they'll think if you don't.

One comes from choice.

The other comes from fear.

And fear is a terrible foundation for making important decisions.

When Being Liked Becomes an Expensive Business Strategy

Some of the most painful lessons I've learned came from decisions I made in business.

I've invested in businesses because I wanted to help someone succeed.

I believed in the person. I wanted to support their vision. I wanted them to know I was in their corner.

And yes, somewhere beneath all that goodwill was the desire to be appreciated for what I was doing.

The problem?

Wanting someone to succeed doesn't make their business a sound investment.

I've learned that lesson the expensive way.

I've also joined companies and committed to projects without doing the level of due diligence I should have.

Sometimes the opportunity looked attractive on paper.

Sometimes the compensation was compelling.

Sometimes I simply wanted to believe in the people involved.

And in certain situations, I later discovered that the leadership was engaged in fraudulent behavior.

Think about that for a moment.

Here I was, someone with decades of business experience, someone who understood risk, accountability, governance, and the importance of asking difficult questions.

Yet I sometimes failed to apply those same principles to my own decisions.

Why?

Because challenging someone's story, questioning their integrity, or walking away from an opportunity might disappoint them.

Or worse, they might not like me.

It's a difficult realization when you recognize that your desire for acceptance has occasionally overridden your own professional judgment.

I knew better.

But knowing better and doing better are two very different things.

The Pattern Didn't Stop at the Office

Unfortunately, this wasn't just a professional problem.

It showed up in my personal relationships too.

I've entered relationships when something inside me was already telling me they weren't right.

I've overlooked incompatibilities.

I've ignored warning signs.

I've stayed involved in situations longer than I should have.

Sometimes because I didn't want to hurt someone.

Sometimes because I wanted to be wanted.

And sometimes because I was more concerned about being liked than whether the relationship was genuinely healthy for either of us.

You can imagine how some of those situations turned out.

Let's just say they weren't all peaceful endings.

Looking back, I can see how often I confused kindness with accommodation.

I believed that being a good partner meant being understanding, flexible, and willing to compromise.

And those qualities absolutely matter.

But compromise without boundaries isn't necessarily love.

Sometimes it's simply abandoning your own needs in the hope that someone else will appreciate the sacrifice.

And here's the irony.

When we repeatedly ignore what we know to be right for ourselves, we often end up creating the very conflict we were trying to avoid.

Resentment builds.

Expectations become distorted.

Communication deteriorates.

And eventually, someone gets hurt anyway.

Often everyone involved.

The Hidden Cost of Saying Yes

For years, my pattern was remarkably consistent.

Someone needed something.

I wanted to help.

I said yes.

Then I figured out how to make it work.

Sometimes that meant working longer hours.

Sometimes it meant sacrificing personal time.

Sometimes it meant taking on financial or professional risks I shouldn't have.

And sometimes it meant making promises I simply didn't have the capacity to fulfill.

Eventually, the consequences would arrive.

Stress.

Exhaustion.

Frustration.

Overcommitment.

And then came the part I was particularly good at.

Blaming myself.

Why did I agree to this?

Why didn't I ask more questions?

Why didn't I listen to my instincts?

Why do I keep putting myself in these situations?

The frustrating thing was that I could usually recognize the pattern afterward.

I just struggled to interrupt it beforehand.

I had spent years learning how to manage business risk.

But I hadn't learned how to protect my own boundaries.

I was willing to disappoint myself repeatedly to avoid disappointing someone else once.

That's a pretty terrible trade.

The Story I Was Telling Myself

Recently, I started looking more closely at why saying no felt so uncomfortable.

Why did I feel responsible for other people's reactions?

Why did I interpret someone's disappointment as evidence that I'd done something wrong?

Why was I so concerned about whether people liked me?

What I began to recognize was that much of this behavior was connected to a story I'd been carrying about myself.

A story that said:

If I'm helpful, people will appreciate me.

If I'm generous, people will value me.

If I make people happy, they'll like me.

If I disappoint them, I might lose their approval.

And beneath those beliefs was a much bigger question.

Why did I need their approval in the first place?

That's where things started getting interesting.

Because the issue wasn't really about learning how to say no.

It was about understanding why I believed saying no might somehow make me less worthy of being liked, valued, or loved.

And that opened a door I hadn't fully appreciated before.

The door to self-worth.

Self-Worth, Value, and Love

We spend an extraordinary amount of our lives looking for validation.

We want to be recognized.

Appreciated.

Respected.

Wanted.

Loved.

And there's nothing inherently wrong with any of those desires.

We're human. Connection matters.

But when our sense of worth becomes dependent on how other people respond to us, we give them an extraordinary amount of influence over our decisions.

Their approval becomes our reward.

Their disappointment becomes our punishment.

And we begin adjusting our behavior to manage their reactions.

I started asking myself some uncomfortable questions.

Why did I need someone else to appreciate my generosity for it to feel meaningful?

Why did I need to be needed?

Why did I sometimes place more importance on someone else's perception of me than on my own judgment?

And why was I so willing to compromise my boundaries when doing so was clearly not serving me?

I don't pretend to have all the answers.

I'm still exploring them.

But one realization has been particularly important.

My value doesn't increase because someone likes me. And it doesn't decrease because someone is disappointed in me.

That may sound obvious.

Intellectually, it is.

Emotionally, learning to live that truth is an entirely different experience.

Something Surprising Happened When I Started Saying No

As I've become more intentional about establishing and communicating boundaries, something unexpected has happened.

People haven't universally rejected me.

In fact, I've found that people often respect me more.

When I'm clear about what I can and cannot commit to, expectations become healthier.

When I ask difficult questions before making an investment, I'm protecting both my interests and the integrity of the decision.

When I decline a project that isn't aligned with my priorities, I'm creating room for commitments I can genuinely honor.

When I communicate honestly in a relationship, I'm giving the other person an opportunity to understand who I actually am.

Not simply the version of me I think they want.

And perhaps most importantly, I'm learning that someone else's disappointment doesn't automatically mean I've done something wrong.

Of course, boundaries don't guarantee that everyone will respond positively.

Some people will be disappointed.

Some may become frustrated.

Some relationships may change.

And that's part of what makes maintaining boundaries difficult.

But I'm beginning to understand that those reactions don't necessarily invalidate the boundary.

Someone can be disappointed in my decision without my decision being wrong.

That distinction has changed the way I think about responsibility.

Boundaries Aren't About Being Selfish

One of the misconceptions I carried for years was that prioritizing my own needs somehow meant I was being selfish.

That saying no was unkind.

That setting limits was a form of rejection.

That being a good leader, partner, friend, or colleague meant being as accommodating as possible.

I see that differently now.

Healthy boundaries aren't about controlling other people.

They're about taking responsibility for ourselves.

Our time.

Our energy.

Our commitments.

Our values.

Our financial decisions.

Our emotional well-being.

And our capacity to show up fully for the people and responsibilities that genuinely matter.

There's also an important distinction between a boundary and an excuse.

Boundaries don't absolve us of accountability.

They don't give us permission to abandon commitments, avoid difficult conversations, or disregard how our decisions affect others.

In fact, I believe responsible boundaries require more honesty, not less.

They require us to communicate clearly.

To make intentional commitments.

To acknowledge our limitations.

And to accept that sometimes the right decision will be unpopular.

That's not selfishness.

That's integrity.

Leadership Requires the Courage to Disappoint

This lesson extends far beyond personal relationships.

It's fundamental to leadership.

Think about how many poor business decisions are made because someone doesn't want to have an uncomfortable conversation.

A leader avoids confronting an underperforming employee.

An executive agrees to an unrealistic deadline.

A business owner accepts a bad deal because they don't want to lose the relationship.

A founder continues funding a failing initiative because they don't want to disappoint the team.

A manager says yes to every request and then wonders why everyone is overwhelmed.

I've seen variations of these situations throughout my career.

And I've participated in some of them myself.

We often associate strong leadership with confidence, decisiveness, and accountability.

But perhaps one of the most overlooked leadership capabilities is the willingness to disappoint people when the alternative would compromise our judgment, values, or responsibilities.

That doesn't mean being insensitive.

It doesn't mean refusing to compromise.

It means recognizing that our responsibility isn't to make everyone happy.

Our responsibility is to make thoughtful decisions, communicate honestly, and act with integrity.

A leader who needs everyone to like them will eventually face a choice between approval and accountability.

And that choice can be expensive.

Learning to Disappoint Without Guilt

I wish I could tell you that after recognizing these patterns, saying no suddenly became easy.

It hasn't.

Decades of behavior don't disappear because we have a moment of clarity.

I still catch myself wanting to agree before I've thought something through.

I still feel the pull to help someone even when I know I don't have the capacity.

I still sometimes worry about how a decision will be received.

But I'm learning to create space between the request and my response.

To ask myself whether I'm making a decision because it aligns with my values or because I want someone's approval.

To distinguish generosity from obligation.

To recognize when I'm agreeing to something out of fear rather than genuine willingness.

And to remember that I don't have to justify every boundary until the other person agrees with it.

Sometimes a thoughtful, respectful no is enough.

I'm also learning something else.

Disappointing someone doesn't necessarily damage a relationship.

Dishonesty, resentment, broken commitments, and unspoken expectations can do far more damage.

A clear no today may be considerably kinder than a reluctant yes that becomes a problem tomorrow.

The Courage to Value Yourself

As I reflect on this pattern, I realize the most important change isn't simply learning to say no.

It's learning to understand and value myself without requiring someone else's approval.

To recognize that I can be generous without being obligated.

Helpful without being responsible for everything.

Compassionate without sacrificing my own well-being.

Ambitious without accepting every opportunity.

Loving without abandoning myself.

And confident enough to make decisions that not everyone will agree with.

I'm still learning.

Still catching myself.

Still exploring the deeper reasons behind behaviors I've carried for much of my life.

But there's something incredibly freeing about recognizing that I don't have to earn my value through constant accommodation.

And neither do you.

My Challenge to You

Think about the last time you said yes to something you really wanted to decline.

Maybe it was a business opportunity.

A financial commitment.

A project.

A social obligation.

A relationship.

Or simply another request for your time.

Why did you say yes?

Was it because you genuinely wanted to?

Because it aligned with your values and priorities?

Or because you were worried about disappointing someone?

Now ask yourself a harder question.

What has your need to be liked cost you?

Financially.

Emotionally.

Professionally.

Personally.

And what might change if you stopped measuring your worth through other people's approval?

I'm not suggesting we stop caring about others.

Quite the opposite.

I believe we become better partners, leaders, friends, and human beings when our generosity comes from genuine choice rather than fear.

When our commitments come from integrity rather than obligation.

When our relationships are built on honesty rather than accommodation.

And when we recognize that our own needs and values deserve consideration too.

I've spent much of my life trying not to disappoint people.

What I'm discovering is that sometimes the person I most needed to stop disappointing was myself.

The courage to disappoint others may be one of the greatest acts of self-respect we ever learn.

And for me, it's becoming one of the most important lessons of my life.

Back to Insights